If Cuccinelli is wrong, then so was Mueller

As reported by Fox News, U.S. district judge Randolph Moss "ruled Sunday that one of the Trump administration's top immigration officials, Ken Cuccinelli, was unlawfully appointed to his post." The Fox News article is a bit off.  The unlawfulness is not because of a statute, as the article claims, but because of the Constitution itself — specifically, the Appointments Clause (U.S. Constitution, art. II, §2, cl. 2).  This is set forth in the first paragraph of the judge's ruling. The position to which Cuccinelli was appointed, as a matter of constitutional law, is that of a superior officer — therefore the appointment to be lawful must — must — be approved by the Senate.  Because the Senate did not approve the appointment, the judge (rightly) concludes, the appointment is unlawful. The judge rightly concludes that such agency actions are to be set aside as either void from the beginning...(Read Full Post)
You must be logged in to comment.