Barcelona and beyond: How politicians and policy wonks play God with your life

No sooner do terrorists attack than those who monopolize the conversation revert to abstractions: "terrorism returned," "terror struck," when, of course, not terrorism, but terrorists struck Barcelona, Spain, on August 17.  Terrorists did the same days later, in Newcastle, England and in Turku, Finland.

The men who murdered 14 in Spain, maiming and injuring over 100, 15 of them critically, are flesh and blood.  Young Muslim Moroccan men with murder on their minds.  It is the duty of governments to bar such men from civilized society or to keep such barbarians at bay.

So drop the Orwellian bafflegab when describing what elites have wrought through their policies.  The Maghrebi Mohammedans – aged, 17, 18, 22, and 24 – had been given free range and limitless access to their victims in the name of those victims' freedoms.  The only lucky sorts living safely are the elites who grant the barbarians license to kill.

Thus were Theresa May, the Spanish royals, and other leaders – well protected courtesy of their taxpayers – able to flout the reality faced by the ordinary fellow and utter fatuities like "these assassins, these criminals won't terrorize us."  The truth is that these darling buds of May and Merkel do and will continue to terrorize ordinary men and women but will spare invulnerable elites for reasons obvious.

Of Spain's many millions, "only" 14 lives were lost in one day, in Barcelona.  Similar numbers obtain in London, Manchester, Melbourne, Paris, Nice, Normandy, Stockholm, Saint Petersburg, Berlin, Hamburg, Columbus (Ohio): only a few people were picked off in each attack, this year.  In the grand scheme of things, the numbers are relatively small – or so we're lectured by the contemptible aggregators who decide who will reside among us.

On TV, June 1, 2017, Alex Nowrasteh, immigration expert at the libertarian Cato Institute, argued that "foreign-born terrorism is a hazard" but a "manageable" one, "given the huge economic benefits of immigration and the small costs of terrorism."

Spoken like a collectivist, central planner, and utilitarian rolled into one.

This is the Benthamite "utilitarian calculus" at its cruelest.  It requires, first, for someone to play God.  Whether she sits in Downing Street, D.C., Brussels, or Barcelona, the Godhead has determined that Muslims in our midst are a must in bringing "the greatest good to the greatest number of citizens."  Along the way, a few people will die.  For the greater good.

In the words of "Stalin's apologist" Walter Duranty, ''You can't make an omelet without breaking eggs.''

However, a natural-rights libertarian values the life of the innocent individual.  Only by protecting each individual's rights – life, liberty, and property – can the government legitimately enhance the wealth of the collective.  Only through fulfilling its night watchman role can government legitimately safeguard the wealth of the nation.  For each individual, secure in his person and property, is then free to pursue economic prosperity, which redounds to the rest.

See, statistics are silly unless given context.  If you have one foot in fire, the other in ice, can we legitimately say that, on average, you're warm?  Hardly.

Probabilities – in this case, the chance that any one of us will die by Muslim – are statistically insignificant...unless this happens to you or to yours, to me or mine.

It is this crude calculus that politicians and policy wonks like the Catoite mentioned peddle.

Would that it were possible to arrange for wonks, pols, and their beloved to pay for the policies they promulgate.  Would that these ugly aggregators were told, "Yes, we like your idea of flooding Western societies with Muslims at the price of a few lives – provided that those lives lost belong to you and yours."  The John McCains and Jeff Flakes of the world would quickly retract their policy follies.

Ilana Mercer has been writing a paleo-libertarian column since 1999 and is the author of The Trump Revolution: The Donald's Creative Destruction Deconstructed (June, 2016) and Into the Cannibal's Pot: Lessons for America From Post-Apartheid South Africa (2011).  Follow her on Twitter, Facebook, Gab, and YouTube.

If you experience technical problems, please write to