Dem Senators back IRS effort to institutionalize targeting of conservative groups
A group of Democratic Senators are asking the IRS to cap the amount of political activity a 501 (C)(4) group can engage in at 5-15%.The request came in public comments tol new IRS regulations that would institutionalize tea party targeting by infringing on conservative groups' right to free speech.
“You will undoubtedly receive complaints from certain corners that these proposed rules will infringe on First Amendment speech rights,” Sens. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) and the other senators wrote to the Treasury Department and the IRS.
“Such complaints are without merit: these rules would not restrict anyone’s right to speak, or to spend money to influence elections,” the senators added. “If implemented properly, the rules will only close a loophole that has until now allowed donors to evade campaign finance law disclosure requirements.”
Treasury and the IRS rolled out the new rules last November, months after the IRS acknowledged and apologized for singling out Tea Party groups. The public comment period on the regulations ends Thursday, with more than 120,000 comments having already been lodged.
Top Republicans have said that the new rules would infringe on First Amendment rights by essentially codifying the IRS’s extra scrutiny of conservative groups. The proposed regulations would apply to tax-exempt groups across the ideological spectrum.
Tea Party groups are coming out hard against the proposed rules, and are fighting alongside the nation's largest business lobby.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce on Thursday raised a slew of objections, arguing the administration is seeking to create a "no speech zone" through "breathtaking overreach."
“This unworkable proposal demonstrates the obvious: the IRS has neither the expertise nor the authority to regulate First Amendment political speech, and should not be used by the administration for political ends,” said Lily Fu Claffee, the Chamber’s general counsel and chief legal officer.
“The proposed rule tramples speech that has never been regulated before, and puts the tax rules in hopeless conflict with themselves and other laws. We urge Treasury and the IRS to withdraw their fundamentally unsound proposal.”
The House voted on Wednesday to delay the rules for a year, and GOP leaders have also called on the IRS commissioner, John Koskinen, to withdraw the regulations.
Under the proposals, 501(c)(4) groups could not count “candidate-related” activity toward their social welfare mission. But the Obama administration also asks for input about how much political activity those groups should be allowed, because of a disparity between the law and current regulations.
And in a brazen effort to evade the new regs in ways that would benefit the Democratic party, the Senators are asking the iRS to totally exempt "non-partisan" voter registration efforts from the definition of "political activity."
So, make sure the IRS screws the Tea Party but let us use groups like ACORN to register as many of our supporters - alive or dead - as we can. Yep - sounds fair to me.
These rules are going forward unless someone can get a judge to issue an injunction preventing them. That's actually likely, but it doesn't help Tea Party groups seeking tax exempt status now. Those groups who have been in tax exempt limbo for years are not likely to have their cases resolved anytime soon.
No matter what happens, it appears that the restrictions imposed by the new rules will be felt whether they are in effect or not.