The other SCOTUS shoe: AZ immigration law

The Obama administration may get hit with a double whammy of bad news this week; not only is SCOTUS contemplating overturning Obamacare, but a decision is also expected in the government's challenge to the Arizona immigration statute.

Wall Street Journal:

he U.S. Supreme Court is set to decide the fate of Arizona's tough anti-immigration law this week, in a ruling likely to affect the national debate over immigration ahead of the November elections. 

The court could strike down the challenged provisions as an intrusion on federal sovereignty, uphold them as a legitimate public-security effort by the state, or take a piece-by-piece approach that could leave both sides claiming victory. Some justices at arguments in April suggested they weren't troubled by a section of the Arizona law directing police officers to check the immigration status of people they stop. 

That section was one of four at issue before the high court. The others make it a crime for immigrants without work permits to seek employment, make it a crime for immigrants to fail to carry registration documents, and authorize the police to arrest any immigrant they believe has committed a deportable offense. 

Lower federal courts blocked those provisions from taking effect after Republican Gov. Jan Brewer signed the measure in 2010. The courts agreed with the Justice Department that they undermined federal authority over immigration. 

The law is part of the broader national debate over immigration, which heated up last week when President Obama and Republican rival Mitt Romney spoke before a group of Hispanic officials. 

This one is probably going to go Obama's way. At least some of the challenged provisions could very well be thrown out, largely because the Supreme Court recognizes an inherent right of the national government to defend our borders - even if they're not doing it. Hopefully, some of the law will survive and give AZ police some of the tools it needs to stem the flow of illegal immigration.



The Obama administration may get hit with a double whammy of bad news this week; not only is SCOTUS contemplating overturning Obamacare, but a decision is also expected in the government's challenge to the Arizona immigration statute.

Wall Street Journal:

he U.S. Supreme Court is set to decide the fate of Arizona's tough anti-immigration law this week, in a ruling likely to affect the national debate over immigration ahead of the November elections. 

The court could strike down the challenged provisions as an intrusion on federal sovereignty, uphold them as a legitimate public-security effort by the state, or take a piece-by-piece approach that could leave both sides claiming victory. Some justices at arguments in April suggested they weren't troubled by a section of the Arizona law directing police officers to check the immigration status of people they stop. 

That section was one of four at issue before the high court. The others make it a crime for immigrants without work permits to seek employment, make it a crime for immigrants to fail to carry registration documents, and authorize the police to arrest any immigrant they believe has committed a deportable offense. 

Lower federal courts blocked those provisions from taking effect after Republican Gov. Jan Brewer signed the measure in 2010. The courts agreed with the Justice Department that they undermined federal authority over immigration. 

The law is part of the broader national debate over immigration, which heated up last week when President Obama and Republican rival Mitt Romney spoke before a group of Hispanic officials. 

This one is probably going to go Obama's way. At least some of the challenged provisions could very well be thrown out, largely because the Supreme Court recognizes an inherent right of the national government to defend our borders - even if they're not doing it. Hopefully, some of the law will survive and give AZ police some of the tools it needs to stem the flow of illegal immigration.



RECENT VIDEOS