Sociologist Sued for Exposing Islamic Jew-Hatred

Andrew G. Bostom
According to Ahlul Bayt New Agency, The Vigilance Musulmane (Muslim Vigilance) advocacy group filed a complaint with the Centre for Equal Opportunities and the Fight Against Racism (CGKR) against VUB professor of sociology Mark Elchardus for statements about Islamic Jew hatred quoted in the De Morgen newspaper (English translation courtesy of Vlad Tepes blog).

Professor Elchardus' conclusions are based upon data from a 426 pp. report he co-authored entitled, "Young in Brussels: findings from the JOP monitor Brussels." Chapter 8 of this study, "Anti-Semitism in Brussels," devotes some thirty pages to highlighting the problem of rising Jew-hatred  in Brussels, particularly amongst young Muslim students. Elchardus provided this overview of the alarming problem to De Morgen: 

Worrying is that half of Muslim students can be described as anti-Semitic...Worse, the anti-Jewish feelings have nothing to do with a low educational or social disadvantage, as is the case with racist natives. It is theologically inspired anti-Semitism..

 
Islam's canonical texts-Koran, hadith, and sira-are redolent with Islamic Jew-hatred as acknowledged-and extolled-by the late Muslim Pope Sheikh Muhammad Sayyid Tantawi, who served as the Grand Imam of Sunni Islam's Vatican, Al Azhar University, for 14 years from 1996, till his death last March 2010. Tantawi's "academic" magnum opus, his 700 page treatise entitled, "Jews in the Koran and the Traditions", includes this summary rationalization of  Muslim Jew hatred:

 

[The] Koran describes the Jews with their own particular degenerate characteristics, i.e. killing the prophets of Allah [Koran 2:61/ 3:112 ], [and see al-Azhar Sheikh Saqr's contemporary Koranic citations, "Jews' 20 Bad Traits As Described in the Qur'an"] corrupting His words by putting them in the wrong places, consuming the people's wealth frivolously, refusal to distance themselves from the evil they do, and other ugly characteristics caused by their deep-rooted lasciviousness...only a minority of the Jews keep their word...[A]ll Jews are not the same. The good ones become Muslims [Koran 3:113 [42]], the bad ones do not.

 

The impact of such sacralized, mainstream Islamic Jew hatred on Western Europe's burgeoning Muslim community is equally apparent. During February of 2008, then European Commissioner for Justice, Freedom, and Security, Franco Frattini, the European Union (EU) official responsible "for combating racism and Antisemitism in Europe," revealed  that Muslims were responsible for fully half (50%) of the documented Antisemitic incidents on the European continent. Demographic data from 2007 indicated that the total number of Europeans is 494.8 million; estimates of the number of Muslims in Europe range from 15-20 million, or some ~3.0-4.0% of the total European population. Thus, on a population percentage basis, Muslims in Europe already accounted for roughly 24.0 to 32.3 times the number of Antisemitic incidents as their non-Muslim European counterparts.

 

These 2007/2008 data were in turn consistent with previous findings from 2006 on the excess prevalence of frank Antisemitism reported amongst European Muslims, published in The Journal of Conflict Resolution by Yale University biostatistician Dr. Edward H. Kaplan, and Dr. Charles A. Small of the Yale Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism. ("Anti-Israel Sentiment Predicts Antisemitism in Europe," Journal of Conflict Resolution, 2006, Vol. 50, pp. 548-561.) 

Drs. Kaplan and Small examined the views of 5004 Europeans, roughly 500 individuals sampled from each of 10 Western European countries (Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom). The authors' main publicized results confirmed their (rather commonsensical) a priori hypothesis: anti-Israel sentiments strongly and independently predicted the likelihood that an individual was Antisemitic in a graded manner, i.e., the more anti-Israel (on a scale of zero to 4), the more a person was likely to be Antisemitic.

 

But a much more striking and relevant finding by Kaplan and Small, given the burgeoning Jew hatred evident in Europe's Muslim communities, received far less attention: in a controlled comparison to European Christians (as the "referent" group), European Muslims were nearly eightfold (i.e., 800%) more likely to be overtly Antisemitic. [emphasis added] ("Anti-Israel Sentiment Predicts Antisemitism in Europe," p. 557 and Table 3, p. 558.) Furthermore, in light of the Pew Global Attitudes Project data on Muslim attitudes toward Jews in Islamic countries, the Yale study likely underestimated the extent of Antisemitism amongst Europe's Muslim communities, had more poorly educated, less acclimated European Muslims been sampled. Pew's earlier international survey indicated ("The Great Divide: How Westerners and Muslims View Each Other," Pew Global Attitudes Project, June 22, 2006.),

 

In the Muslim world, attitudes toward Jews remain starkly negative, including virtually unanimous unfavorable ratings of 98% in Jordan and 97% in Egypt. Muslims living in Western countries have a more moderate view of Jews -- still more negative than positive, but not nearly by the lopsided margins that prevail in Muslim countries.

These are the larger doctrinal and data-driven contexts for Professor Elchardus' specific findings in Belgium. Rather than being maliciously sued, the Professor should be commended by all decent people for his intellectual honesty and moral courage. Let us hope more brave European politicians like Tanguy Veys rally to Elchardus' defense against those malevolent Muslim advocacy groups who deny the scourge-and origins-of the rampant Islamic Jew-hatred in Europe.

According to Ahlul Bayt New Agency, The Vigilance Musulmane (Muslim Vigilance) advocacy group filed a complaint with the Centre for Equal Opportunities and the Fight Against Racism (CGKR) against VUB professor of sociology Mark Elchardus for statements about Islamic Jew hatred quoted in the De Morgen newspaper (English translation courtesy of Vlad Tepes blog).

Professor Elchardus' conclusions are based upon data from a 426 pp. report he co-authored entitled, "Young in Brussels: findings from the JOP monitor Brussels." Chapter 8 of this study, "Anti-Semitism in Brussels," devotes some thirty pages to highlighting the problem of rising Jew-hatred  in Brussels, particularly amongst young Muslim students. Elchardus provided this overview of the alarming problem to De Morgen: 

Worrying is that half of Muslim students can be described as anti-Semitic...Worse, the anti-Jewish feelings have nothing to do with a low educational or social disadvantage, as is the case with racist natives. It is theologically inspired anti-Semitism..

 

Islam's canonical texts-Koran, hadith, and sira-are redolent with Islamic Jew-hatred as acknowledged-and extolled-by the late Muslim Pope Sheikh Muhammad Sayyid Tantawi, who served as the Grand Imam of Sunni Islam's Vatican, Al Azhar University, for 14 years from 1996, till his death last March 2010. Tantawi's "academic" magnum opus, his 700 page treatise entitled, "Jews in the Koran and the Traditions", includes this summary rationalization of  Muslim Jew hatred:

 

[The] Koran describes the Jews with their own particular degenerate characteristics, i.e. killing the prophets of Allah [Koran 2:61/ 3:112 ], [and see al-Azhar Sheikh Saqr's contemporary Koranic citations, "Jews' 20 Bad Traits As Described in the Qur'an"] corrupting His words by putting them in the wrong places, consuming the people's wealth frivolously, refusal to distance themselves from the evil they do, and other ugly characteristics caused by their deep-rooted lasciviousness...only a minority of the Jews keep their word...[A]ll Jews are not the same. The good ones become Muslims [Koran 3:113 [42]], the bad ones do not.

 

The impact of such sacralized, mainstream Islamic Jew hatred on Western Europe's burgeoning Muslim community is equally apparent. During February of 2008, then European Commissioner for Justice, Freedom, and Security, Franco Frattini, the European Union (EU) official responsible "for combating racism and Antisemitism in Europe," revealed  that Muslims were responsible for fully half (50%) of the documented Antisemitic incidents on the European continent. Demographic data from 2007 indicated that the total number of Europeans is 494.8 million; estimates of the number of Muslims in Europe range from 15-20 million, or some ~3.0-4.0% of the total European population. Thus, on a population percentage basis, Muslims in Europe already accounted for roughly 24.0 to 32.3 times the number of Antisemitic incidents as their non-Muslim European counterparts.

 

These 2007/2008 data were in turn consistent with previous findings from 2006 on the excess prevalence of frank Antisemitism reported amongst European Muslims, published in The Journal of Conflict Resolution by Yale University biostatistician Dr. Edward H. Kaplan, and Dr. Charles A. Small of the Yale Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism. ("Anti-Israel Sentiment Predicts Antisemitism in Europe," Journal of Conflict Resolution, 2006, Vol. 50, pp. 548-561.) 

Drs. Kaplan and Small examined the views of 5004 Europeans, roughly 500 individuals sampled from each of 10 Western European countries (Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom). The authors' main publicized results confirmed their (rather commonsensical) a priori hypothesis: anti-Israel sentiments strongly and independently predicted the likelihood that an individual was Antisemitic in a graded manner, i.e., the more anti-Israel (on a scale of zero to 4), the more a person was likely to be Antisemitic.

 

But a much more striking and relevant finding by Kaplan and Small, given the burgeoning Jew hatred evident in Europe's Muslim communities, received far less attention: in a controlled comparison to European Christians (as the "referent" group), European Muslims were nearly eightfold (i.e., 800%) more likely to be overtly Antisemitic. [emphasis added] ("Anti-Israel Sentiment Predicts Antisemitism in Europe," p. 557 and Table 3, p. 558.) Furthermore, in light of the Pew Global Attitudes Project data on Muslim attitudes toward Jews in Islamic countries, the Yale study likely underestimated the extent of Antisemitism amongst Europe's Muslim communities, had more poorly educated, less acclimated European Muslims been sampled. Pew's earlier international survey indicated ("The Great Divide: How Westerners and Muslims View Each Other," Pew Global Attitudes Project, June 22, 2006.),

 

In the Muslim world, attitudes toward Jews remain starkly negative, including virtually unanimous unfavorable ratings of 98% in Jordan and 97% in Egypt. Muslims living in Western countries have a more moderate view of Jews -- still more negative than positive, but not nearly by the lopsided margins that prevail in Muslim countries.

These are the larger doctrinal and data-driven contexts for Professor Elchardus' specific findings in Belgium. Rather than being maliciously sued, the Professor should be commended by all decent people for his intellectual honesty and moral courage. Let us hope more brave European politicians like Tanguy Veys rally to Elchardus' defense against those malevolent Muslim advocacy groups who deny the scourge-and origins-of the rampant Islamic Jew-hatred in Europe.