« NYT admits its writer intentionally lied |
Blog Home Page
| One Small Step for Sanity »
October 21, 2008
Wall Street Journal: Obama 'Nonsense' on tax cuts
Not that this is going to get any play beyond a few conservative sites but it is still a devastating indictment of Obama's tax plan.
William McGurn in the Wall Street Journal:
Now we know: 95% of Americans will get a "tax cut" under Barack Obama after all. Those on the receiving end of a check will include the estimated 44% of Americans who will owe no federal income taxes under his plan.
In most parts of America, getting money back on taxes you haven't paid sounds a lot like welfare. Ah, say the Obama people, you forget: Even those who pay no income taxes pay payroll taxes for Social Security. Under the Obama plan, they say, these Americans would get an income tax credit up to $500 based on what they are paying into Social Security.
Just two little questions: If people are going to get a tax refund based on what they pay into Social Security, then we're not really talking about income tax relief, are we? And if what we're really talking about is payroll tax relief, doesn't that mean billions of dollars in lost revenue for a Social Security trust fund that is already badly underfinanced?
Austan Goolsbee, the University of Chicago economic professor who serves as one of Sen. Obama's top advisers, discussed these issues during a recent appearance on Fox News. There he stated that the answer to the first question is that these Americans are getting an income tax rebate. And the answer to the second is that the money would not actually come out of Social Security.
"You can't just cut the payroll tax because that's what funds Social Security," Mr. Goolsbee told Fox's Shepard Smith. "So if you tried to do that, you would undermine the Social Security Trust Fund."
As McGurn points out, Goolsbee is not being entirely honest. In fact, those who pay no income taxes will have indeed receive a check based on their payroll taxes which will affect how much is being paid into the Social Security Trust Fund:
You have to admire the audacity. With one touch of the Obama magic, what otherwise would be described as taking money from Peter to pay Paul is now transformed into Paul's tax relief. Where a tax cut for payroll taxes paid will not in fact come from payroll taxes. And where all these plans come together under the rhetorical umbrella of "Making Work Pay."
Independent contractors such as myself will receive the least because our taxes are figured a little differently. No matter, a scheme is a scheme and I wonder if someone will point all this out to the Messiah before he prematurely bankrupts Social Security.